BatilSlayer Library

The contingency argument demonstrates that there must be an independent, eternal, conscious, and willing entity (Allah) through clear reasoning about existence itself.

Everything we see exists in one of two ways:

1. Contingent (Dependent) Existence: Things that exist but don't have to exist, and depend on something else for their existence. A tree depends on soil, water, and sunlight. You depend on your parents, food, and oxygen.

2. Necessary Existence: Something that must exist, cannot not exist, and depends on nothing else for its existence.

The universe itself is contingent and depends on something else for its existence:

1. The universe is made up of things like stars, planets, and people---all of which could have not existed

2. The universe changes, began at a certain point (the Big Bang), and depends on laws, constants, and conditions

3. If the universe could have been different, or not existed at all, it is not necessary---it is contingent

Simple case: If you see a cup on a table, you know it didn't have to be there---it depends on someone putting it there. Similarly, the universe didn't have to exist; something must explain why it does.

Imagine a soldier needs to fire a bullet, but before firing, he must ask his commanding officer for permission. That officer must ask his senior officer, who must ask his senior officer, and so on up the chain of command.

If this chain went on infinitely:

1. Even with unlimited time, the bullet would never be fired

2. Each person is waiting for approval from someone above them

3. No one in the chain has the authority to give the final order

There must be a highest-ranking officer who:

1. Doesn't need to ask anyone for permission

2. Has the authority to give orders independently

3. Can break the chain by making decisions

The same applies to existence:

1. Every contingent thing depends on something else for its existence

2. If this chain went on infinitely, nothing would ever exist

3. But things do exist, so there must be something that exists independently

The logical steps:

1. We exist (undeniable fact)

2. Our existence depends on our parents, who depend on their parents, etc.

3. This chain of dependence cannot go on infinitely

4. Therefore, there must be a necessary being that exists independently

Our very existence proves this necessary being exists - because if it didn't exist, nothing dependent could exist.

The Key Question: Since nothing forces this independent being to act (it has no superior or external cause), why does anything else exist at all?

The Answer: Only will and consciousness can explain why the necessary being would create or cause anything.

Using our analogy:

1. If the highest-ranking officer had no will or consciousness, he couldn't decide to give the order to fire

2. The order would never be given, and the bullet would never be fired

3. But since the "bullet" (our existence) was "fired" (we exist), the highest authority must have willed it

Similarly:

1. If the necessary being had no will, nothing would happen - it would remain static

2. The fact that contingent things exist shows the necessary being chose to create them

3. Only a conscious being with will can make choices about what to bring into existence

Without will and consciousness:

1. There would be no reason for anything to come from the necessary being

2. The necessary being would be like an unconscious force that just "is" but does nothing

3. Our existence would be unexplainable

Some might argue: "Maybe things just happen randomly or spontaneously from the necessary being, like uranium decaying randomly."

The response:

1. Random events in nature (like uranium decay) still happen within a system of physical laws and conditions

2. The necessary being has no external system or conditions - it is completely independent

3. Randomness provides no explanation for why something specific happens rather than nothing at all

4. Only will can provide a true explanation for why anything exists

The analogy: If our commanding officer gave orders randomly without any reason or consciousness, there would be no explanation for why specific orders were given rather than others, or why orders were given at all rather than silence.

Key principle: Nothing without will or consciousness can do anything without external interference.

1. Will and consciousness are what allow a being to choose, decide, or initiate something on its own

2. Inanimate objects or entities without will/consciousness only change when influenced by something else

3. Random events in nature follow laws or probabilities within existing systems - they are not true self-initiated actions

4. Only a being with will can initiate action without being acted upon by something else

1. We exist - this is undeniable

2. The universe is contingent - it could have not existed and depends on other things

3. Contingent things depend on other things - trees need soil, we need parents

4. Infinite chains of dependence are impossible - like the chain of command example, nothing would ever happen

5. Therefore, a necessary being exists - something independent that explains all dependent existence

6. This necessary being must have will and consciousness - because only a conscious being with will can choose to create or cause anything

7. Therefore, there exists an independent, eternal, conscious, and willing being - which is Allah

This argument demonstrates the existence of Allah as described in Islam - Al-Wajib (the Necessary One), Al-Hayy (the Living), Al-Murid (the One who wills), and Al-Khaliq (the Creator). The argument shows that Allah exists by necessity, acts by His will, and is the ultimate explanation for all existence.

The proof is complete: Our existence itself is the evidence that there is an independent, eternal, conscious, and willing Creator who chose to bring us into being.